How Lean Tools Lead to Waste and What Managers Need to Do About It

„For a man with a hammer everything seems to be a nail.“ This saying also applies frequently for the use of lean tools. With great enthusiasm plenty of lean tools are getting trained in order to achieve higher efficiency and profitability. However, in truth all this tool training is a huge waste.

Werkzeug, Werkbank, Kind
Lean Tools Add Waste

Typical lean tools that are trained with little benefit:

_ 5S
_ SMED
_ Kanban
_ Just in Time
_ Jidoka
_ Kaizen Workshops
_ Standardized Work
_ Visualization
_ Value stream
_ A3 Problem Solving
_ TPM, etc.

This type of training of lean tools is peddled to organizations with the promise of improvement. Unfortunately, the situation does not improve, but mostly it is deteriorating. Why? Because used in this way the tools are searching for the right problems.

In addition there is a psychological phenomenon. As we learned from nobel prize winner Daniel Kahneman, we tend to replace a difficult, complex problem, whose solution is hard for us, with a known problem, where we have smooth, easy solution. This may sound ignorant, but is probably practiced by all of us at times. Really dumb, however, seems to be the fact that we don´t like to admit our self-deception.

With lean management this means that we do have many difficult problems in our operations, where a lasting solution would greatly pay off. However, instead of trying to understand the problem thoroughly on site (gemba) and starting the hard path of step-wise improvement, we prefer instead to just “implement” the lean tools. Voilá, the problem seems solved! (Or not, as it is revealed shortly thereafter.)

Therefore the difficult problem (e.g. profit decline) is replaced with a simple problem (e.g. lacking lean skills), where the solution is an elementary training that can be provided quickly and simply.

Complex Problems Require Profound Solutions

The mistake with this kind of “solutions approach” consists of the fact that at our workplace we face problems with a complexity too high, than that they could be resolved with simple tools.

The true task requires us to eliminate all causes and obstacles that prevent us from fulfilling a customer order in one flow from receiving to delivery of the product, using the minimum of time, cost and effort.  As Taiichi Ohno said:

„All we are doing is looking at the time line, from the moment the customer gives us an order to the point when we collect the cash. And we are reducing the time line by reducing the non-value adding wastes.”

Aim and Function of Lean Tools

The purpose and benefit of lean tools is to support employees and managers to clearly identify value and to immediately and urgently highlight waste. This waste then can be eliminated quickly and for good.

That means for example, not the introduction of just-in-time transforms the operation to become lean. Just-in-time only helps to see the problems that prevent us from a highly value added operation.

The reason is that only when the worker really depends on every supplied part, then it becomes paramount to develop and practice quality and reliability for the actual work and for the long term. Everything else is just pretty words.

Ultimately, lean cannot be established by implementing lean tools. Lean tools can only support people to solve their problems and overcome their challenges in order to deliver higher value.

Managers still need to step up to their responsibility, take an impartial look at their true problems and implement effective counter-measures on the basis of sound factual analysis. And yes, lean tools can be pretty helpful at this!

For questions and comments reply here or send an email to me at sattlberger@procon.at

 

 

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s